Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Its not the same though is it. In your example there can be a cause of death identified as radiation poising which can be attributed to the residue in his house.

With the VW example, you cant quantify it at all. How much has it shortened peoples lives? 2 seconds? 10 years? nanoseconds? Its not a direct correlation, theres no graph you can plot with emissions against length of life, and so claiming that there is a direct correlation is Hyperbole.



> With the VW example, you cant quantify it at all. How much has it shortened peoples lives? 2 seconds? 10 years? nanoseconds? Its not a direct correlation, theres no graph you can plot with emissions against length of life

https://theicct.org/sites/default/files/NOx%20Health%20Fact%...

> According to new research published in Nature, NOX from diesel vehicle exhaust was linked to 107,600 premature deaths worldwide in 2015. Of these, ~38,000 are attributable to excess NOX emissions.

Sounds like the graphs do exist. (Obviously VW is only a fraction of those specific numbers.)


I really tried to give it a go, and accept what this link is trying to say.

But when you read it, literally everything used in creating those numbers is an estimation. Ther are no measurements whatsoever.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: